Determining the purchase price of a company: Methods, factors and legal principles

kaufpreis unternehmen ermitteln

The most important facts at a glance

Why determining the purchase price is crucial

Determining the appropriate purchase price for a company is one of the most complex tasks in business life. Whether selling a company, changing shareholders or succession planning - a precise valuation forms the foundation of every successful transaction.

Many entrepreneurs underestimate the complexity of this task. The value of a company is not just a calculation figure, but also reflects future potential, market position and strategic opportunities. An incorrect valuation can lead to considerable financial losses or failed negotiations.

Legal basis of company valuation

Legal reasons for valuation

The purchase price is not determined in a legal vacuum. Various laws provide for valuation obligations:

Corporate law eventsSection 728 (1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) regulates the entitlement to a settlement commensurate with the share value in the case of severance payments to departing shareholders; a proper company valuation is generally required to determine this share value.

Valuation under tax lawThe German Valuation Act (BewG) contains its own valuation regulations for tax purposes, which are particularly relevant for inheritance and gift tax via Section 11 of the German Inheritance Tax Act (ErbStG); income tax regulations also apply, for example in the assessment of hidden profit distributions.

Commercial law aspectsIn connection with restructurings - particularly in the case of mergers under the German Reorganization Act (UmwG) - accounting and valuation rules under commercial and reorganization law must be observed; recognized business valuation methods have been developed in practice for determining compensation or exchange ratios.

IDW standards as a basis for valuation

With IDW S 1, the Institute of Public Auditors in Germany has developed a comprehensive standard for company valuation, which describes in particular the capitalized earnings value method as the central method and explains the classification of other methods (e.g. market-oriented approaches, net asset value as a supplementary value) depending on the purpose of the valuation.

In company law valuation disputes, the courts are often guided by the IDW standards (in particular IDW S 1), whereby the Federal Constitutional Court emphasized the importance of recognized business valuation methods in the so-called DAT/Altana decision and the Federal Court of Justice has continued this line in its case law.

Main methods of determining the purchase price

Income capitalization approach: Future-oriented valuation

The capitalized earnings value method focuses on the earning power of the company. The expected future earnings are discounted to the valuation date.

Basic principleThe method is based on the idea that a company is only worth as much as it can generate in earnings. The decisive factor is the sustainable annual net profit after tax.

Planning calculationThe centerpiece is a detailed financial plan for the next five to ten years. This includes sales, cost and investment forecasts as well as the derivation of free cash flows.

Capitalization rateDiscounting is based on a risk-adjusted interest rate, which is composed of the risk-free prime rate and a company-specific risk premium.

This method is particularly suitable for established, profitable companies with predictable business trends. It takes future potential into account and is therefore often the preferred method for corporate transactions.

Net asset value method: Asset-oriented approach

The net asset value is based on the existing company assets. It determines the costs that would be incurred to set up an identical company.

Full reproduction valueAll tangible and intangible assets are recognized at replacement cost. These include land, buildings, machinery, but also internally generated intangible assets such as customer base or know-how.

Partial reproduction valueOnly takes into account the assets required for continuation. Superfluous or inefficiently used resources are not taken into account.

The net asset value method is mainly used for asset-intensive companies or as a lower value limit. In practice, it is often used as a plausibility check for other valuation methods.

Market price method: Orientation towards comparable transactions

The market price method derives the company value from the prices of comparable transactions. This is based on multiples that represent valuation ratios to parameters such as sales or EBITDA.

Listed peer group companiesFor listed companies, valuation multiples can be derived directly. These are transferred to the company to be valued.

Transaction multiples: Sector-specific valuation benchmarks are developed from completed company acquisitions. Specialized databases record the corresponding transaction data.

The method is particularly helpful for an initial assessment and for the market validation of other valuation approaches. However, it requires sufficient comparative data.

Valuation-relevant factors in detail

Financial performance indicators

Financial performance forms the backbone of every company valuation. Key figures are:

Sales developmentNot only the absolute amount, but also growth trends and stability are decisive. Recurring sales are valued higher than volatile business.

ProfitabilityEBIT, EBITDA and net profit show the operational strength. The sustainability of profits and their development trend are particularly important.

Cash flow generationOperating cash flow shows the actual generation of liquidity. A stable cash flow indicates a solid business basis.

Balance sheet structureEquity ratio, gearing and working capital requirements influence both the risk profile and the scope for financing.

Market position and competitive environment

The strategic position determines the future viability of the company:

Market share and positionMarket leaders typically achieve higher valuations than downstream competitors. The ability to defend the position is crucial.

Customer structureA diversified customer base reduces default risks. Dependence on major customers reduces the valuation.

Unique selling pointsUnique products, patents or special skills create competitive advantages and increase the company's value.

Industry dynamicsGrowth sectors are valued higher than stagnating or shrinking markets. Digitization trends are increasingly influencing the valuation.

Management and organization

The quality of corporate management has a direct influence on value:

Management skillsExperienced, high-performing managers increase the value of the company. However, dependence on the owner can reduce the valuation.

Succession planningClearly regulated succession, especially in family businesses, reduces risks and stabilizes value.

Organizational structureEfficient processes, clear responsibilities and modern IT systems create value potential.

Practical implementation of the assessment

Data collection and processing

A well-founded assessment requires comprehensive information:

Historical financial dataAnnual financial statements for the last three to five years, BWAs, tax balance sheets and supplementary evaluations form the data basis.

Planning dataBudgets, forecasts and strategic plans show the future prospects. The plausibility of the assumptions must be critically scrutinized.

Market and industry dataExternal information on market developments, the competitive situation and industry trends supplement the internal view.

Develop a valuation model

The selection and application of valuation methods requires expertise:

Selection of methodsDifferent approaches are useful depending on the reason for the valuation and the characteristics of the company. A combination of several methods increases reliability.

Parameter determinationGrowth rates, margins, investment requirements and risk premiums must be realistically estimated.

Sensitivity analysesThe effects of changed assumptions on the enterprise value should be examined.

Quality assurance and validation

Various plausibility checks ensure the quality of the valuation:

Comparison of methodsThe results of different valuation approaches should lie within a comprehensible range.

Market comparisonComparisons with transaction multiples or listed companies provide external reference points.

Expert assessmentThe assessment by independent experts can validate the valuation.

Avoid common valuation errors

Overestimation of synergy effects

Buyers tend to be too optimistic about synergies:

Cost savingsDuplicate structures often cannot be completely eliminated. Social costs and integration time are underestimated.

Sales synergiesCross-selling potential and market development are more difficult to realize than expected.

Time delaysSynergy effects usually occur later and to a lesser extent than planned.

Neglect of integration risks

The merger of different corporate cultures harbors risks:

Cultural differencesDifferent working methods and value systems can lead to frictional losses.

Employee turnoverKey personnel may leave the company, resulting in a loss of expertise.

Customer lossesUncertainty about the future of the company can unsettle customers.

Underestimating the tax consequences

Transactions often have significant tax implications:

Capital gainsSales usually result in taxable profits, which reduce the net proceeds.

Structural designThe choice of transaction structure has a significant impact on the tax consequences.

Subsequent tax risksTax audits can lead to additional payments, which must be taken into account in the valuation.

We support you with, to avoid these stumbling blocks and develop a realistic assessment.

Checklist for determining the purchase price

Preparation of the valuation

  • Define the reason for and purpose of the valuation
  • Determine key date and valuation standard
  • Collect complete financial data for the last 3-5 years
  • Create current planning calculations
  • Carry out market and industry analysis

Selection and application of methods

  • Select suitable evaluation procedures
  • Develop sustainable revenue planning
  • Determine risk-adjusted interest rates
  • Analyze comparison transactions
  • Carry out sensitivity analyses

Quality assurance

  • Check plausibility of the valuation parameters
  • Compare the results of different methods
  • External validation through market data
  • Documentation of the valuation principles
  • Consider legal and tax aspects

Negotiation and implementation

  • Identify scope for evaluation
  • Develop a negotiation strategy
  • Accompanying the due diligence process
  • Define purchase price adjustment clauses
  • Choose a tax-optimized transaction structure

Professional support from experienced consultants can help to take all aspects into account appropriately.

Frequently asked questions

What valuation methods are available for companies?

The three main methods are the capitalized earnings value method (future-oriented), the net asset value method (asset-oriented) and the market price method (comparison-oriented). In practice, several methods are often combined in order to determine a realistic valuation range.

A well-founded valuation typically takes 4-8 weeks, depending on the size of the company and the availability of data. Complex structures or international issues can extend the time frame.

Annual financial statements for the last 3-5 years, BWAs, tax balance sheets, planning calculations, shareholder agreements and information on the market and competition. You will receive a complete list in our initial consultation.

Tax burdens can have a significant impact on the net sales proceeds. The choice of transaction structure and timing aspects are decisive for tax optimization.

The costs depend on the scope of the valuation and the size of the company. In an initial non-binding consultation, we will discuss transparently the anticipated work involved and the associated costs for your individual situation.

The standards of the Institute of Public Auditors in Germany form the recognized basis for professional valuations in Germany. Courts are regularly guided by these standards.

A rough estimate is possible, but for legally relevant occasions or complex transactions, a professional valuation by qualified experts is recommended.

Customer base, know-how, brands and patents often have considerable value, but are difficult to quantify. Professional valuation helps with appropriate recording.

Common mistakes include exaggerated future forecasts, neglecting risks, incomplete data bases and the wrong choice of methods. External consulting helps to avoid these.

In the event of major changes (market environment, business model, financial situation) or every 3-5 years at the latest, the valuation should be updated.

Your contact person

Tobias F. Faller

Partner, auditor and tax consultant

en_USEnglish