Typical silent employee participation: BFH (VIII R 13/23) confirms capital income even with leaver clause and very high return

The most important facts at a glance

Summary of the judgment

A senior employee was a division manager and authorized signatory. He had already concluded a contract with the GmbH in 2010 for a typical silent partnership. The participation was intended to retain particularly important employees. The contribution could be made not only in cash, but also by leaving bonuses and other remuneration entitlements or by crediting future profit shares. The tax office wanted to treat the profit shares as wages. The tax court and BFH disagreed.

 

Classification in the BFH line: participation is a special legal relationship

The decision fits stringently into the demarcation line:

  1. A typical silent partnership is basically a capital investment for tax purposes. The silent partner provides capital, while the owner remains the sole legal entity.
  2. Wages only exist if the payment is made for the provision of labor. If the reason lies in the special legal relationship under company law, Section 19 EStG does not apply.
  3. The decisive factor is that the special legal relationship is effectively established, seriously agreed, actually implemented and has its own economic content in addition to the employment relationship.

Important for practice: The BFH clarifies that no individual case assessment is required for current remuneration to determine whether Section 19 or Section 20 is “closer”. If Section 20 is fulfilled, Section 20 remains applicable.

 

Three typical salary indicators that did not work here

1) Link to the employment relationship

The contractual termination of the silent partnership upon termination of the employment relationship does not automatically deprive the participation of its independent legal character.

2) Very high profit shares above the nominal amount

The BFH expressly does not check the appropriateness of the current income. Even a very high return in relation to the investment does not lead to reclassification as wages.

3) Participation only for selected key employees

In the case in dispute, the participation was even expressly designed as an instrument for “selected, particularly important employees”. This was not a supporting lever for wages.

 

Typical use cases in the SME sector

  1. Retention of key persons without giving up voting rights: Family limited liability companies want to involve key players, but not co-control under company law. Typically still provides participation in success without external impact as a shareholder.
  2. Growth financing with a variable return: deposits from managers can strengthen liquidity. The return is profit-dependent and adapts to the earnings situation.
  3. Plannable remuneration architecture instead of bonus escalation: Instead of negotiating new bonus logics every year, a clear, formula-based participation model is established.
  4. Succession and management commitment in transition phases: When an entrepreneur hands over gradually, a typical silent partnership creates economic windfall profits without opening up the shareholder structure.

 

Sources of error

  1. If the client actually wants to grant a genuine co-entrepreneurial status, a different structure is typically relevant, e.g. genuine participation or atypical silent partnership. This leads to different tax consequences.
  2. If the GmbH wants to control the profit shares “by feel”:
    As soon as the amount of the remuneration is de facto dependent on the employer's discretion, the salary risk increases considerably. The BFH line emphasizes precisely the causation by the special legal relationship and the actual implementation.
  3. If you want to covertly “relabel” a variable activity-based remuneration:
    This is regularly unsustainable and can be challenged in audits.

 

Design points

 

1) Genuine contribution and clear capital commitment: The contribution must “exist” economically and must not only exist on paper. The BFH ruling cited shows that leaving remuneration claims unpaid can also be a contribution if it is contractually „cleanly“ structured as a contribution.

 

2) Formula-based profit model: remuneration according to a clear quota or calculation formula, e.g. contribution in relation to the defined total capital.

 

3) Loss participation and limitation: Typically silent means regular loss participation up to the amount of the contribution. This supports the investment character.

 

4) Leaver rules are permissible, but must be drawn up properly: Termination on departure is possible without automatically generating wages. Nevertheless, the severance payment mechanism and valuation logic should be clear and in line with external standards.

 

Implementation and documentation

Actual implementation is mandatory: account management, profit determination, resolutions, payments must comply with the agreement. The BFH focuses precisely on this.

Separation of acquisition versus current income: A potential non-cash benefit typically arises in the case of a discounted acquisition. This does not “infect” the current profit shares if the special legal relationship is independent.

 

Capital gains tax registration

Profit shares from typical silent partnerships are regularly subject to capital gains tax deduction in accordance with Section 43 (1) No. 3 EStG. In practice, this is often overlooked and can lead to liability risks for the paying company.

 

Your contact person

Tobias F. Faller

Partner, auditor and tax consultant

en_USEnglish